All guides

Workers comp experience mod and your electrical bids: what to know

An experience mod, also called an EMR, is a multiplier on your workers’ compensation premium. A mod of 1.00 leaves the premium as is. A mod below 1.00 lowers it, and a mod above 1.00 raises it. Because workers’ comp is part of the cost of every field hour, your mod belongs in your labor burden, and some owners and agencies also ask for it when they screen bidders.

This guide explains where the mod comes from, how it moves through an estimate, and what to check before you bid. It is written for estimators and owners at small electrical contractors.

What is an experience mod?

The National Council on Compensation Insurance (NCCI) describes experience rating as a way to tailor the cost of insurance to the employer. It compares the experience of an individual employer with the average employer in the same classification. The result is the mod, which may increase, decrease or leave the premium unchanged.

The South Carolina DOT’s contractor evaluation policy puts it this way: a contractor whose losses equal the industry standard would have an EMR of 1.00. NCCI says a mod is a unity (1.00) factor, a credit mod or a debit mod. Better-than-average loss experience generally earns a credit mod, and worse-than-average experience carries a debit mod.

Not every state uses NCCI. Per NCCI’s 2025 guide, the plan does not apply in California, Delaware, Michigan, New Jersey, New York or Pennsylvania, or in the four states that run their own plans (North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming). Indiana, Massachusetts and North Carolina produce their own in-state mods, and the independent bureaus in Minnesota and Wisconsin join the plan only for employers with exposure in two or more participating states. Ask your insurance agent which bureau issues yours.

How is the mod calculated?

You do not need to run the formula yourself. Your insurer or agent gets the mod from the rating bureau. It still helps to know what drives it, per NCCI’s ABCs of Experience Rating:

  • Three years of history. The experience period is generally based on three years of payroll and loss data. The newest policy year is left out. A policy that renews on January 1, 2026 generally uses the policies effective 1/1/2022 through 1/1/2025.
  • Primary and excess losses. Each claim is split at a state-approved point. NCCI’s example uses $18,500. The part up to that point is “primary” and the rest is “excess.” Primary losses carry more weight, so many small claims can hurt a mod more than one large claim.
  • Medical-only claims count less. In most states, the mod includes only 30% of a medical-only claim, a 70% reduction.
  • Size matters. The larger the employer, the more its own claims drive the result. A small shop can go years without a claim, then have one injury cost many times its premium, and the plan tempers that swing.
Which policy years feed a 2026 mod and a 2027 mod
  1. 1/1/2022 to 1/1/2023Used in the 2026 mod only
  2. 1/1/2023 to 1/1/2024Used in the 2026 and 2027 mods
  3. 1/1/2024 to 1/1/2025Used in the 2026 and 2027 mods
  4. 1/1/2025 to 1/1/2026Not yet reported for the 2026 mod; used in the 2027 mod

NCCI's example of an employer whose policy renews on January 1, 2026.

Source ncci.com

A new business with no history, or a company too small to qualify, gets a mod of 1.00. Eligibility is set by each state’s premium threshold.

How does the mod change the premium?

It is a straight multiplier. NCCI’s example starts with a $100,000 premium before the mod:

Premium after the mod, on a $100,000 starting premium
Mod 0.75$75000
Mod 1.00$100000
Mod 1.25$125000

NCCI's Exhibit E example. Premium and mods are NCCI's illustration, not a benchmark for electrical work.

Source ncci.com

For a contractor, the same multiplier applies to the workers’ comp line of your labor burden rate. The base rate comes from your state and classification codes, so two shops with the same crew can pay different amounts before the mod is applied.

How does the mod show up in an electrical estimate?

Workers’ comp follows the wage. Each field hour you price carries a comp cost, so a higher or lower mod moves the loaded rate on every labor line. It does not change your material or equipment costs.

Here is an illustrative example with made-up numbers. Suppose a base comp rate adds $2.40 per hour to a $30.00 wage at a mod of 1.00. At a mod of 1.25 the same line is $3.00. At 0.75 it is $1.80. The swing is a little over a dollar an hour, which on a job with several thousand labor hours is real money. Your rates and hours will differ.

A few habits keep this clean:

  • Use the mod in force. Mods generally apply for one year and a new one is calculated for the next, per NCCI. Update your burden when the new one arrives, not when the old bids are done.
  • Know the effective date. Ask your agent when the next mod takes effect, and check it against the dates of long jobs.
  • Keep it out of overhead. Comp for field employees is burden. Counting it again in overhead double counts the dollar.
  • Do not guess. Ask your agent for the current mod and the classification rates that apply to your crews.

Why do owners ask for your EMR?

Some owners and agencies use the mod as a quick read on safety performance. A mod can be a bid requirement, a scored item or a form field, so read the prequalification section of the instructions to bidders. The details differ by owner.

One public example is the South Carolina Department of Transportation. Its contractor performance evaluation policy (revised November 1, 2013) uses the contractor’s current EMR as the safety measure in a scoring system. The policy says the EMR is not related to a particular size or type of project. That is one agency’s method. Other owners may use a hard cutoff or not ask at all, so the bid documents are your source.

If an owner asks for a mod, have the rating bureau worksheet or a letter from your agent ready. A new company with no mod usually gets the default 1.00 treatment under NCCI, but some owners handle new firms differently, so ask early.

What can you do about a high mod?

NCCI says a safe workplace, including safety programs, puts an employer in a better position for a credit mod, and a debit mod may be a reason to review those programs. Because the formula weights claim frequency heavily, small and repeated claims matter. NCCI also notes that involvement by the employer can reduce the severity of losses once they happen, and that the plan gives an incentive to return injured employees to work as soon as reasonably possible.

You can also check the data. Mod worksheets list the claims in the calculation. Ask your agent to walk through them and to flag anything that looks wrong, so errors can be raised with the bureau. This is a question for your insurance professional, not a place for a quick fix.

A short checklist before you bid

  1. Get the current mod and its effective date from your agent.
  2. Confirm the classification rates for your field crews.
  3. Update the workers’ comp line in your burden rate.
  4. Read the prequalification and safety sections of the bid documents.
  5. Keep the mod worksheet where you can find it when an owner asks.

Where Amptake fits

Amptake is being built to handle the counting step of the takeoff, so there is more time before the deadline for work like checking your burden rate and prequalification forms. It is also being built to show every count on the drawing for your review, and insurance decisions stay with you and your agent. Join the waitlist.

This guide is general information, not insurance, legal or financial advice. Workers’ compensation rules, rates and mods vary by state and carrier, so confirm your numbers with a licensed insurance professional.