How to price an electrical change order without leaving money behind
To price an electrical change order, build it in three parts: the direct cost of the changed work, overhead and profit applied on the correct base, and any consequential costs that the change causes elsewhere on the job. Then write down every piece. Cost is where most change order arguments start, and the contractor carries the job of proving the number.
This guide walks through those three parts using published industry research. It is written for estimators and owners at small electrical firms who price changes between bids.
Why do change order prices get disputed?
A 2018 summary of ELECTRI International’s change order guidelines says that “the single most common area of dispute in the change order process is its cost.” The same summary says the contractor has to “make a professional case with detailed substantiation/calculations.”
The Ottawa Construction Association’s 2023 Change Order Protocol splits the cost into the same three groups:
| Cost group | What it covers | Why it is disputed |
|---|---|---|
| Direct costs | Labor and materials for the changed work | Easy to identify, but labor rates and hours get questioned |
| Overhead and profit | A markup, usually a percentage | The percentage and the base are often contested |
| Consequential costs | Knock-on effects of the change or delay | Hard to identify and measure |
The protocol also notes that tender documents often leave limited room for overhead and profit on changes. So read the contract before you build the price.
What direct costs should you include?
Start with the obvious items: labor hours, material, and any equipment. Then look for the ones that get missed. An EC&M article from 2016 lists several:
- Time spent analyzing, discussing, estimating, managing and presenting the change.
- Extra drawings, plan revisions and cost analysis.
- Whether your labor rate covers safety meetings, cleanup, supervision, warranty work and employer burdens.
- Material bought at a different price or on a different date, separate delivery charges, and rental equipment that bills daily or monthly.
If you already build a loaded labor rate for bids, use the same one here. Our guide to the electrician labor burden rate shows how.
How should you add overhead and profit?
Many contracts and habits use a flat markup. The EC&M article calls the “all-too-common” 10% for overhead and 5% for markup likely not enough to cover true costs, and it describes flat markups of 5% to 10% as often arbitrary. It points to an ELECTRI International study, released in December 2014, that put the average electrical contractor’s overhead at 19.16%.
The base matters as much as the rate. ELECTRI’s guidance is that overhead should be calculated as a share of the total change order amount, not only of direct costs.
Here is an illustrative example, with made-up round numbers, based on the method in the EC&M article. Suppose overhead is 19% of the total price. Then direct costs are 81% of it. To recover the overhead you need a markup of 19 ÷ 81, about 23.5%, on direct costs. A 19% markup on direct costs would recover only about 16% of the total price.
Profit works the same way. The article shows that to earn a 5% profit on the total price, the markup on cost is 0.05 ÷ 0.95, or about 5.3%.
Your own overhead will differ from the study average. Work it out from your own books, and ask your accountant how to treat each expense.
What are consequential costs?
These are the costs of the change that do not show up in the changed work itself. The EC&M article lists impact factors such as:
- Stacking of trades.
- Reassignment of manpower.
- Dilution of supervision.
- Interference with site access.
- Seasonal and weather conditions.
The article says the ELECTRI report identifies more than 15 types of consequential cost. ELECTRI’s guidance is that the burden is on the contractor to support them with detailed substantiation. A line that says “impact, 10%” with no backup invites a fight. Show the dates, the crews affected and the hours lost.
How fast should you send the price?
The EC&M article, describing ELECTRI’s principles, sets a 30-day target for the whole cycle: 15 days for the contractor to quote and 15 days for the owner to approve. Your contract may set its own deadlines and notice rules, so check them first. If you are unsure what your notice terms require, ask a construction attorney.
A short checklist before you send a change order
- Read the contract’s change clause for allowed markup, notice rules and deadlines.
- List all direct costs, including the planning and drawing time.
- Use your loaded labor rate and current material prices.
- Apply overhead and profit on the base the contract allows.
- Add consequential costs only with backup.
- Show the build-up line by line so the owner can follow it.
Where Amptake fits
Amptake is being built to count devices and fixtures on revised plan sets and show each count on the sheet for your review, so a change can be priced from the same counts and labor units as the bid. You still decide the markup and the impact costs. Join the waitlist.
This guide is general information, not legal or accounting advice. Change order rights, notice rules and allowable markup depend on your contract and your state, so check with a construction attorney or accountant.