All guides

Overtime in an electrical estimate: premium pay and lost productivity

Overtime costs an electrical contractor twice. You pay a premium rate for each extra hour, and the crew may get less done in each hour it works. A bid that carries only the premium pay still comes up short. Decide before you bid whether the schedule needs overtime, then price both effects or write an exclusion.

Why is overtime more than a pay rate?

Federal wage law sets the first cost. The U.S. Department of Labor says that, unless exempt, covered employees must receive overtime pay for hours worked over 40 in a workweek, at a rate not less than time and one-half their regular rates of pay.

The second cost is slower work. The Construction Industry Institute (CII) studied scheduled overtime on four active industrial projects and reported efficiency losses of about 12% for 5-day weeks and 14% for 6-day weeks (CII publication SD-98, 1994). The authors said these results likely show a lower limit of losses, because the projects had no severe schedule or labor problems.

Efficiency loss from scheduled overtime, CII study
5-day weeks12%
6-day weeks14%

Four industrial projects, 1994. Electrical work on your jobs may differ.

Source construction-institute.org

The same study found that shortages of materials, tools, equipment or information rise sharply as work weeks get longer. Its authors concluded that efficient overtime is mainly a resource management problem. That matters for an estimator: overtime goes better when material, tools and information are ready before the crew arrives.

What do older studies say about long overtime?

A 1980 Business Roundtable report, Scheduled Overtime Effect on Construction Projects, says that work weeks of 60 hours or more, sustained beyond about two months, cause cumulative productivity losses. Those losses can delay completion compared with a 40-hour week. The report also suggests options such as adding a shift when overtime cannot be avoided.

The studies are not electrical-only and they are not recent. Use them to see the direction and rough size of the effect, not as a number to paste into your bid.

What is the premium pay math?

Time and a half applies only to hours over 40 in a week, so the average premium depends on how long the week is. Here is an illustration, not a quote:

Week Hours paid at 1.0 Hours paid at 1.5 Pay-equivalent hours Average premium
40 hours 40 0 40 0%
48 hours (6 x 8) 40 8 52 about 8%
50 hours 40 10 55 10%
60 hours 40 20 70 about 17%

Your own agreements may differ. A union agreement, a state law or a prevailing wage determination can set a different rule, such as double time or daily overtime. Read the one that applies to your crew.

Federal work adds a rule of its own. Under the Contract Work Hours and Safety Standards Act, contractors on covered contracts must pay one and one-half times the basic rate for all hours worked over 40 in a workweek. The Department of Labor lists the threshold as over $150,000 for most direct federal construction contracts, and over $100,000 for some others, including certain federally assisted contracts. Check your contract to see whether it applies.

How do you combine premium pay and lost output?

Treat them as two steps. First, adjust the hours for lower output. Then apply the premium to the hours worked beyond 40.

Illustrative example only: suppose your base estimate is 1,000 labor hours at a normal 40-hour week. The schedule forces 6-day, 48-hour weeks. Assume output per hour falls 14%, borrowing the CII figure above. CII’s 6-day weeks were likely longer than 48 hours, so this probably overstates the loss for a 6 x 8 week.

  • Hours needed: 1,000 / 0.86 is about 1,163 hours.
  • Pay-equivalent hours at the 8% average premium: 1,163 x 52 / 48 is about 1,260.
  • Result: about 26% more labor cost than the base estimate, before burden on the premium and before any change in material or equipment cost.

The point is the shape, not the number. A 14% output loss means about 16% more hours, and the 8% premium sits on top of those hours, so the total lands near 26%. Carry a premium alone and you cover less than a third of that. Whether you should assume a 14% loss on your own crews is your call, based on your records.

Where does overtime show up on bids?

Overtime usually comes from the schedule, not from your estimate. Watch for these in the documents:

  • A compressed schedule or a fixed completion date with penalties.
  • Work that must happen after hours in an occupied building.
  • Shutdowns, outages or cutovers on weekends.
  • A late start behind other trades, with no relief on the finish date.
  • Addenda that move dates without moving scope.

If the work only fits in a normal week on paper, say so in your clarifications. Do not assume your crew will absorb a crunch for free.

How should you price or exclude it?

You have three honest choices:

  1. Carry it. Add the premium and lost-output hours to the affected tasks, and show the assumption in your notes.
  2. Exclude it. State working hours in the proposal, for example 7:00 a.m. to 3:30 p.m., Monday through Friday, and state that overtime or shift work is excluded or priced as an add. Check that the bid form allows qualifications first.
  3. Price it as an alternate. Give a separate add price for an accelerated schedule.

Then read your own history. If past jobs ran long weeks and you never tracked the hours, the data to support a number is missing. Start logging scheduled overtime by job and by task so the next estimate rests on your records.

A short overtime check before you submit

  • Did you compare the schedule to your crew size and the hours in the base estimate?
  • Does the bid require after-hours or weekend work?
  • Did you price premium pay, lost output, or both, or exclude overtime in writing?
  • Is material, tooling and information ready early enough to avoid the resource shortages CII linked to long weeks?
  • Did you check whether a union agreement, state law or a federal contract changes the overtime rule?
  • Does your proposal state working hours and how overtime is handled?

Where Amptake fits

Amptake is being built to count devices and fixtures on a plan set, show each count on the drawing and build a bid from your own labor units and supplier pricing. The schedule review and the call on overtime stay with you. Join the waitlist for early access.

This article is general information, not legal, wage-and-hour or tax advice. Overtime rules differ by state, union agreement and contract, so check the ones that apply to you with a qualified professional.