Electrical bid exclusions and clarifications: what to write and where
An exclusion tells the customer which work is not in your price. A clarification states the documents and assumptions your price rests on. Write both in your proposal letter, in plain words, so nobody can say later that the work was “obviously” included. On some public bids you may not be allowed to add them, so check the bid form first.
Why do exclusions matter on an electrical bid?
Your proposal letter is the first written record of what you priced. An EC&M estimating series calls it “the first legal correspondence of what your price includes and doesn’t include” (Part 10, October 2011). If the letter is vague, you may end up arguing about whether a gap was in your price.
A good letter does three jobs:
- It says what you carried (inclusions).
- It says what you did not carry (exclusions).
- It says what your price assumes (clarifications, also called qualifications).
What should the proposal letter include?
The same EC&M article suggests this order:
- Project name, address and job number.
- The drawings your bid is based on, with their dates.
- Addenda and bid clarifications received, with their dates, so you can show which documents you priced.
- Included items: lighting, controls, branch devices, big-ticket items and wiring methods.
- Whether fees, permits, sales tax or utility charges are in the price.
- Exclusions.
- Terms, including how long the proposal is good for and your working hours.
The article gives an example of why detail helps: if the specs call for Schedule 80 conduit instead of Schedule 40 on the primary, spell that out. It notes that some contractors also write the price out in words, and it says to list each alternate as an add or a deduct.
What do electrical contractors usually exclude?
The EC&M article lists these common exclusions: cutting, patching and painting; concrete housekeeping pads and transformer or generator pads; site pole bases; and concrete encasement of duct banks.
A vendor guide from Hard Hat Industry Solutions (copyright 2023) adds sample exclusions that estimating software can carry as standard text. Some examples from its list:
- Excavation, backfill and compaction
- Temporary power or light
- Barriers for transformers or switchboards
- Plan check fees and engineering
- Utility company service charges
- Phone and data cabling
- Generator fuel beyond a four-hour test
Treat these as examples to react to, not a list to paste into every bid. Your list should match the job in front of you.
How specific should an exclusion be?
Specific enough that a reader cannot assume the work is covered. The vendor guide says to be very specific about what you are excluding. As an illustration of our own, “excavation and backfill by others” leaves less room for argument than “sitework excluded.” Name the item, and say who does it if the documents tell you.
For existing items, EC&M says to exclude them and make a note of that. For work assigned to the general contractor or another trade, mark it “by others” rather than leaving it unaddressed.
What is the difference between an exclusion and a clarification?
An exclusion removes work. A clarification explains the basis of the price. Examples of clarifications, written as illustrative wording only:
- “Priced from drawing set dated [date], including Addenda 1 through 3.”
- “Working hours are Monday through Friday, 7:00 a.m. to 3:30 p.m.”
- “Price assumes the building is open and power is available for testing.”
The EC&M article gives a sample for working hours (“Monday through Friday, 7 a.m. to 3:30 p.m., excluding major holidays”) and warns that you never want to get stuck paying your crew overtime because you did not exclude overtime work.
Can you add exclusions on a public bid?
Not always. Some public owners ask for a price on a set form and limit what you may add to it.
A South Carolina state-modified sample of the AIA A701 instructions to bidders (1997 edition) shows how strict it can be. Section 4.1.4 says a bidder shall not make stipulations or qualify his bid in any manner not permitted on the bid form. It adds that information attached to the bid form that could be considered a qualification may be cause for rejection of the bid.
The same sample says in § 3.2.1 that the bidder shall study and compare the bidding documents and shall at once report errors, inconsistencies or ambiguities to the architect. It says in § 3.2.2 that requests for clarification must be made in writing and reach the architect at least ten days before bids are due, and in § 3.2.3 that interpretations are made by written addendum.
The practical lesson, which does not depend on that sample’s exact numbers:
- Read the instructions to bidders before you write a single exclusion.
- If qualifications are not allowed on the form, ask your question early, in writing, in the way the documents require.
- If an answer changes the documents, expect it to arrive as an addendum, and price from the addendum.
- If you still cannot price a scope gap, ask whether you may submit a separate qualification letter, or decide whether to bid at all.
Your project may use a different edition or an owner’s own rules. Read the ones that apply to you.
A short exclusion checklist before you send the bid
- Does each exclusion name a specific item?
- Did you list the drawing dates and every addendum?
- Did you mark existing items and “by others” work?
- Did you state permits, fees, taxes and utility charges either way?
- Did you state working hours and exclude overtime?
- Did you state how long the price is good for?
- Does the bid form allow what you wrote, or will it be read as a qualification?
- Does your list match the takeoff? If a takeoff line is excluded, remove its cost. If a cost is carried, do not exclude it.
For example, a letter that says “temporary power excluded” while the estimate carries a temporary panel confuses everyone, including you.
Where Amptake fits
Amptake is being built to count devices and fixtures on a plan set, show each count on the drawing and build a bid from your own labor units and supplier pricing. Deciding what to exclude, and wording it for the job, stays with you. Join the waitlist for early access.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Bid rules and contract language vary by owner, agency and state, so read your own bid documents and ask an attorney about wording that matters.